While Fionna loves Jake & Micah catnip toys, I’ve found nothing to compare to these simple felt catnip mice. Micah loved them too. Unfortunately, Petco and Petsmart have discontinued carrying these babies. Such a simple concept and super cheap too. I’d pick up a pack of 3 every couple months for around $4. Not good for a catnip fix but good for exercise. These are the only toys Fionna will play fetch with. I’ve tried other stuffed shapes and other mice, the furry ones, the canvas ones, foil balls etc. For some reason both Micah and she love to carry these specific guys in their mouths until they are worn out to the point of the stuffing coming out. I’m down to 4 of these guys in really bad shape. I’ve been looking for months for replacements. Fionna is getting thick around the middle and needs exercise BAD. Well I found that Smart Cat makes their version of these simple mice so I ordered 12 of them! Yup that should hold us for awhile. Since no less than 4 of these go missing at a time under the couch or console, 12 should keep us in good shape for awhile. I love the new brighter colors too.